#3
I think
Bibio nigritus Curran, 1924, or
Bibio bryanti Johnson, 1929 if that is a distinct species. They used to be synonyms. I have not seen the latest literature on northern
Bibio.
The key to North American species (Hardy, 1945) relies on length of inner spurs of fore tibia and r-m crossvein relative to basal section of Rs. Those are not clearly visible. Most guesses lead to dead ends. One leads to a species that matches your photo.