Who is here? 1 guest(s)
 Choerades marginata?
|
|
| nick upton |
Posted on 01-01-2018 12:36
|
|
Member Location: Posts: 815 Joined: 12.03.10 |
Black robber fly with golden hairs on legs and abdomen, c 8mm in ancient woodland in SW UK. New to me and a nationally scarce species not yet recorded in Wiltshire if I'm correct, though I may not be. NB UK species records have it as C. marginatus rather than C. marginata.
Nick Upton - naturalist and photographer |
|
|
|
| nick upton |
Posted on 01-01-2018 12:37
|
|
Member Location: Posts: 815 Joined: 12.03.10 |
Pair mating on same day 26.6.17
Nick Upton - naturalist and photographer |
|
|
|
| Quaedfliegh |
Posted on 01-01-2018 21:11
|
 Member Location: Posts: 2198 Joined: 18.05.10 |
Choerades marginata or femorata. In NL we name it also C. marginatus but the feminine version seems to be correct. http://www.latin-dictionary.net/definition/9462/choeras-choeradis C. femorata is very similar but has slightly longer antennae than marginata and the shiny facial hair is usually white(more yellowish in marginata). In the near future Die Raubliegen Deutschlands will be published and I think we will find a solution there. Greetings, Reinoud Field guide to the robber flies of the Netherlands and Belgium: https://www.jeugdbondsuitgeverij.nl/product/field-guide-to-the-robberflies-of-the-netherlands-and-belgium/ https://www.nev.nl/diptera/ |
 |
|
| nick upton |
Posted on 02-01-2018 16:11
|
|
Member Location: Posts: 815 Joined: 12.03.10 |
Many thanks Reinoud. I can't find records of C. femorata in the UK and think it may only be on mainland Europe, so this is likely C. marginata if our recording is accurate. I found this good key to German Asilids http://www.robberflies.info/keyger/htmle/keychoerades.html which gives the key antennal differences, though my photos don't show the antennae clearly enough.
Nick Upton - naturalist and photographer |
|
|
|
| Quaedfliegh |
Posted on 02-01-2018 22:27
|
|
Member Location: Posts: 2198 Joined: 18.05.10 |
C. femorata has long been regarded as synonym to marginata, that is probably the reason why it was never taken into account (also in the NL). In the NL probably all/most marginata specimens are actually femorata. Your specimens look more like femorata too because of the white facial hair. Just an observation; in France I collected quite a few specimens with yellow facial hair and all in a fir forest. In NL you will hardly ever find "marginata" in coniferous forests. So, I suspect that marginata is a species of coniferous forests and femorata of deciduous forests.
Greetings, Reinoud Field guide to the robber flies of the Netherlands and Belgium: https://www.jeugdbondsuitgeverij.nl/product/field-guide-to-the-robberflies-of-the-netherlands-and-belgium/ https://www.nev.nl/diptera/ |
|
|
|
| andrewsi |
Posted on 03-01-2018 09:57
|
|
Member Location: Posts: 214 Joined: 15.08.09 |
The UK list assumes the derivation is from the patronymic -ades in Greek nouns, which is masculine, so it should be femoratus. According to the UK checklist, Choerades was treated as feminine only because species within it were originally considered part of the feminine Laphria genus. The derivation is obscure, but taking it as Choer-ades might give the derivation 'son of a pig'. An alternative would be that it comes from the feminine plural noun choerades meaning 'scrofulous swellings in the neck', which would mean marginata could be right. I suppose it comes down to whether the name was inspired by pigs or scrofulous sores... 
Edited by andrewsi on 03-01-2018 09:58 |
|
|
|
| nick upton |
Posted on 03-01-2018 14:48
|
|
Member Location: Posts: 815 Joined: 12.03.10 |
Many thanks to you both for the extra info on C. marginta/us/femorata. Sounds like some taxonomic revision is needed for this Genus/Species to bring some clarity and hopefully the German work will do that. The current taxonomy seems more like a pig's ear than a sore to me at the moment! These links suggest that the status of C. marginatus / C. femorata is currently undecided in the uk. http://www.dipteristsforum.org.uk/t3261-Request.html http://www.dipteristsforum.org.uk/t1027-Choerades-marginatus%3F.html The location was a deciduous woodland ride, and the facial hairs do look white not yellow, so C. femorata does seem the most likely true ID and that name needs to be added to the UK list! Edited by nick upton on 07-01-2018 19:00 Nick Upton - naturalist and photographer |
|
|
|
| Piluca_Alvarez |
Posted on 05-01-2018 08:51
|
 Member Location: Posts: 2431 Joined: 06.11.10 |
For the last Choerades paper, we asked people from the International Code of Zoological Nomenclature in order to solve this confusing situation and after consulting the original description of the genus Choerades , this was the answer: Choerades is the vocative plural of choeras – and is feminine. It refers to a swelling of glands in the neck. |
|
|
|
| andrewsi |
Posted on 05-01-2018 18:13
|
|
Member Location: Posts: 214 Joined: 15.08.09 |
Piluca_Alvarez wrote: Choerades is the vocative plural of choeras – and is feminine. It refers to a swelling of glands in the neck. 'Vocative' plural would surely be wrong, unless they have started talking to flies! Nominative plural...possibly. |
|
|
|
| Jump to Forum: |
